14 November 2026

Palestine...a theological mess

 It´s now more than a month since me and Emma came back from Palestine.
I still don´t really know how to share or where to start. During the 7 weeks we stayed there I really had no time to write down all my impressions so it´s really hard now for me to process all I´ve seen, heard and experienced. I'm an introvert so, not having regular time to recharge myself from social interactions, apart from the travelling times when I would close my eyes, put my earplugs on and listen to some music, meant finding it really hard to reconnect with my feelings and thoughts which were many.


I´m very grateful to be home and to be able to have a lot of time on my own to recover. To be free to do what I need at this moment, to have my own daily schedule, to have lots of time to sing, pray, write, study, walk with the dogs through our beautiful forested surroundings and feed our chickens, ducks and geese every morning and evening. Soon we will be picking our olives to make olive oil for the year. I am very aware and grateful for my privilege as a white Portuguese Woman living in rural Portugal. Most people don´t have this privilege, if they have 9-5 jobs and a few weeks holidays during the year. Palestinians don't have this privilege, because all their freedoms were taken away from them unjustly and there are very reduced options left. 
Many, if they could choose, they would also live in land and of the land, with chickens and possibly sheep and goats to feed their families and make a living, but they can´t. No access to their own lands. Those who have lands and are now trying to pick their olives, for olive oil and sustenance for the whole family, are now being chased and attacked by jewish settlers with machine guns. Not so much now as repercussions and collective punishment is getting worse, but when a Palestinian have the misfortune to react by throwing stones back, which is not the wisest move but that is probably what each one of us would want to do in the same situation, they are either shot and killed in the spot or filmed and reported as a "terrorist". If the Israeli Defense Forces get involved is to protect the jewish settlers, so the Palestinians end up in jail too on top of it all. I heard rumours but I didn´t want to know details about life in prison for a Palestinian. 

 I thankfully didn´t witness any direct violence, but a lot of indirect ones. I saw human rights being broken every single day I was in Palestine. I saw criminal acts, sanctioned by international law, being perpetrated in front of my eyes. Criminal acts done by those with legal authority to enforce justice, yet they are the ones acting unjustly. This is very serious because if it is allowed in one place, why not in others?

As a follower of Christ and the God whom all religions in that region profess to worship and follow, the scenario is quite disturbing. It was disturbing 20 years ago and it was even more disturbing now as violence, terror and oppression escalated significantly against Palestinians, not only in Gaza but all over the West Bank and the Palestinian cities and communities in Israel (in Galilee, the Negev and East Jerusalem).
 
The difference in treatment is appalling, the apartheid policy is obvious. The access to freedom of movement, the access to natural resources and the access to public facilities is all in the hands of the Israeli Government and Palestinians only receive what this Government decides to give (sell). There are physical gates throughout the whole occupied territory of Palestine that can close off all the cities and villages if the Israeli Government so decides. All natural resources are controlled and distributed by the Israeli Government. Palestinians don´t have a monetary currency, so they depend on Israeli banks to have money in their banks to run their local economies. All fuel is supplied and distributed by Israeli companies. Most food is produced by Israeli farms, even by illegal settlements in Palestine who have access to running water, electricity and good access roads, while Palestinians themselves have no access to any of this, sometimes literally next door. Lets keep in mind that these illegal settlements and farms are built in lands that used to be from the same Palestinian families that now cannot access their own lands or use their own resources.




It´s a really evil and dehumanising way to treat other human beings who live next door to you, or on the other side of a massive cement wall or a high barbed wired fence. I felt I was visiting several open prisons and people subjected to the most horrific tortures and daily humiliations.

It´s almost hard to understand how evil humans can be, but it is not to be understood, the fact is that humans are very able to be this evil. This is disturbing, but generally accepted because we know deep inside ourselves that it is true.

Thankfully we are also able to Love the same way, if not more.

It is also nothing new, or exclusive to a specific kind of human or nationality. Looking back at our human history, we can see the same evil in many shapes and forms. Possibly every generation is able to see, directly or indirectly, this much evil in their lifetime. Many empires have risen, the same way that they had fallen. The Bible is full of stories with similar atrocities and instead of learning something, we repeat them again. Maybe because most people are still reading these stories through the lenses of those who thought they were more special than all others and who believed God was an all powerful God who was obviously on their side. Our history is filled with similar sad stories when some humans thought they were superior and better than others. Look at the European "discovery" times with all the plunder of lands, destruction of cultures, domination over others and ultimately all the horrific ways of slavery that left countless people groups, nations and generations hurt and traumatised. Also in the name of Christ.

Look at the way the jews were mocked and treated in Europe , even before the 3rd Reich came to power. That dehumanisation of the Jews led to Hitler´s "cleansing" ideals who also used the Sacred texts to justify it all. During the holocaust, Germany was more than 98% Christian.

Look at America now... Another Empire built on top of the blood and misery of all the first Nations in the Continent. They also used the Holy Scriptures for their benefit and called the new land their "promised land" where the new settlers, thieves and murderers were now the only chosen ones to become the great Nation they are today and be a blessing to the whole world. We surely see that happening don't we? Another shameful example of christian history... Evangelical Christians from USA are some of the big supporters of the illegal settlement movement in Israel and today's Genocide by the Israeli Government. Look at the British Empire, the Portuguese Empire, the Spanish Empire, they all carried the cross of Christ behind the cannons, in each sword and each gun.

I don't know why, but since I came back I just want to dive deep in Theology and I wish I could have more answers than questions as I struggle with God and try to discern my place and my response in the face of all these sufferings of today, all these oppression, torture, violence, hatred and all the evil humans can come up with.

Consciously or not, some people blame God for all the evil in the world, because God is not doing anything about it. It´s one of the major questions we have. What to do with all this evil? How to think about it?

Well, if people believe God is like that, then I don't believe in God, at least not that God.

That is a God who is supposedly All powerful and all knowing, right? That´s why people pray to this God. People ask this God to stop wars and suffering, or people blame this God for allowing all the suffering they see and experience in the world.

Well, did we ever stop to think that God might not be all powerful and all knowing? I would start there.

For me God is Love, Compassionate, Merciful. God is Peace and Justice and Wisdom and Light. God is Good at all times. And God has no favourites. God in humans, fully alive is like Jesus was. That´s my God, that´s what I put in my altar to worship and try my best to know and learn from.

In my mind, God cannot simply be all powerful and able to stop and destroy all evil alone. How could God be like that and not do anything about it? What would God be waiting for? How many people will still have to die and suffer? If I see God as all powerful I see God as evil then.

What does it even mean to destroy all evil ? An atomic bomb or something? A special chip that God installed in our bodies that can be switched off or some other sci-fi theory? This idea of God doesn't make any sense to me. It's also not helpful because this same image also sees God as a punishing God, and interprets some evil as deserved. Putting it in other words, people suffer because they did something wrong in the eyes of God, and people are blessed because they are good before God. This is the portrait of God that most of us grew up with in the west through these 3 Abrahamic faiths.

Some teaching also says that Jesus defeated evil on the cross. How come? What are we seeing in front of our eyes then? Maybe cosmically Jesus death and resurrection symbolises what is to come. Or maybe Jesus was showing us how to defeat evil. Not with violence or by force, but by resisting it non-violently, even if that means to die. 

 I cannot see God as an All powerful Force anymore,  instead I see God as a Divine Spirit, a Divine Force and Intelligence which Essence is Pure Love, who actually cannot destroy all evil alone. Evil is in each human being, as much as Love is, or God, if you prefer. God is in all and God loves all humans and all creation. God created us all as free beings, so God is not in control as many people may think. We are many free beings who have the same capacity to love as to do evil. God can only deliver us from evil, as much as we choose the ways of God and Love, instead of evil. Is this making sense?

 It´s a dilema isn´t it? Even if God could destroy all evil, God wouldn't as that would mean destroying all human beings and possibly all creation. 
( I also believe there are external evil entities who take advantage and might influence the evil in us , but that's a topic for another long text) 

"...and do not let us fall into temptation, but deliver us from evil." (Jesus´ prayer)


Evil is in us, human beings. All of us, whether active or not. I see it in me, I see it in others, and I don´t consider myself a bad person in particular. We are all in essence good and created to be good, but somehow we all have a potential to feed evil thoughts that lead to evil actions. When we are hurt and we can't forgive, it's easier to let evil thoughts creep in. The same when we hurt others and are not forgiven. Forgiveness can be another tool to destroy evil. But forgiveness is not excusing evil. True forgiveness and reconciliation has to come with justice and reparation.

Evil can also become our god, as so many humans choose today, especially those in places of authority and power. They can be particularly tempted to use that authority and power for their own benefit, or the sole benefit of their relatives, nation, culture or race. It´s the biggest temptation. Curiously Jesus was offered a place of authority and power over all the kingdoms of the Earth as one of his temptations. That authority and power was not being offered by God whom he called his Father. Interesting, isn't it?

Jesus speaks about the wheat and grass growing together and therefore we can´t just uproot everything, or we are left with nothing. We would stop being human. Like wheat and grass, the potential for good and evil is within us. Eventually the wheat overtakes and it´s easier to separate what is good in me and discard what is not good and no longer serves. Only I can do that work in me, as I open my consciousness to the Spirit of God who can show me the things that do not serve me and do not do me, or others, any good.


God cannot be all powerful because God does not have a physical body to intervene in the physical world. God counts on those who are available to listen and be used. God is Spirit. We are spirit and a body in this existence. God is also not aware of every single choice of every free human being on earth, so God cannot be an All knowing God either. God is in the present, as all creation. We are all co-creating and responsible for the future of all. We are needed by God and all Creation. We are the Humus with hands, "Hu manos". We are the hands, not only of the Earth, but also of the Divine Spirit in whom we live, and move and have our being. 

( I'm aware I'm making a lot of affirmations about how God is or God is not, and just want to be clear that this is only one perspective and one possibility among many. I guess that's what theology means)

I believe God is willing to help those who seek God´s guidance, those who seek to do good, even if they don´t believe in God. God needs us in order to defeat evil. 
For me that is what prayer, meditation or contemplation is all about. More than asking God what we wish to happen, we are listening to the Spirit of God in us and expressing God's will. It's about listening to the Spirit speaking to us, teaching us, leading us and sometimes showing us solutions which might involve our actions.

We met many incredible people ( Christians, Jewish, Muslims and non-religious activists) who are being instruments of God´s Spirit to do good, to resist evil non-violently, to speak for the oppressed, to work for justice, peace and the welfare of their communities and ultimately giving their lifes in behalf of others.


When us humans are not open to do this work, inward and outward, we are susceptible to allow evil to grow and our consciousness to be closed to God´s guidance who would like to help everyone to see the evil in us and get rid of it. We can sometimes help others to see their evil, but is best to leave any conviction to the Spirit. We mind our own first, instead of pointing at the others.

Only humans, with the help of God´s Spirit in us, can end all evil, I come to believe. One by one, not a super powerful intervention of God, not politics, not a mighty warrior or a Messiah, not even the millions of daily wishful prayers spoken by believers of all faiths and all Gods.

If nobody would respond to evil, evil would not have any power.  


God cannot be an all powerful and interventionist God, unless this God is really a bad one. That crossed my mind, considering that the 3 main religions in Israel/Palestine: Judaism, Christianity and Islam - all believe in this God of Abraham, who is supposedly an Almighty God who chose them to be the only blessed ones in the whole world. The big problem with this, in my opinion, is that holding this belief means either the full destruction of all other cultures, or a worldwide conversion to one of them which would be a disastrous loss of our beautiful diversity. (I think all of these great religions, at some time in history, and until today unfortunately, have been trying both of these approaches).

I read the Hebrew Scriptures and the Christian texts as a source of Wisdom and as a way to know this God "in whom we live and move and have our being". 
It could be a way to learn about Love and Justice and Peace, right? But what do I see as fruits, coming from those who worship this texts and call them Sacred? Rotten bad fruits... An image kept coming to my mind of a parable Jesus shared : "A good tree cannot bear bad fruits, and a bad tree cannot bear good fruits"...


"Are the Scriptures bad?", I asked God. I prefer to think that the common interpretations are bad. "Are you bad? Where are you God?", I continue to ask as I struggle to make sense of all this evil and how can we allow this to come to this state. " What can we do?"

"Where are you God?" God is with those who are suffering. God suffers with those who suffer and God is not in approval of any oppressor, even if God loves them too. God is Justice, so in the oppressor´s consciousness there will be judgement and I don't think anyone needs to be involved in this apart from God.

We were there in Jerusalem during the Sukkot Holidays, or the "Feast of the Tabernacles" as it´s most known in English. I This is the time when the "Torah" (Jewish Sacred texts and the first 5 books of the Christian Bible) comes to the end of its reading cycle and a new cycle begins. These days the big heavy scrolls are worshiped by the Jews and even secular Israelis who like the tradition as it is something like our "christmas" when everyone gathers to celebrate. Jerusalém was filled with Jewish from all over the country and all over the world. In each sinagogue they sang and dance in circles and different people carried the Scrolls in turns. Others did the same thing in front of the "walling wall". The Torah seems to be the main focus of worship for most Jews today since their second Temple in Jerusalem was destroyed. Sadly it is the same for a lot of Christians, especially the most evangelical.


A beautiful scene of devotion, but somehow creepy when I know the way that these texts and scrolls are so distorted and misinterpreted by some Jews and Christians who are using it irresponsibly to oppress others and justify all sorts of violence and evil. They might be "using the name of God in vain", I dare to say, yet, I would be the one pointed as heretic. I´m not a scholar or an expert, but I´m a lover of God and a seeker, and I just cannot  agree with a lot of the actions that are being defended and perpetrated by those who say they are following what these Scriptures are telling them to do.

I cannot agree that God is commanding anyone to destroy cities , to kill foreigners, to rape women, to support any genocide, to stone people to death, to sacrifice animals or to use any violence against anyone else. Yet, these are the kind of things that are written in these sacred texts as commands from God Godself. Those who interpret them literally and factually, are justifying their actions based on what is written in a book , or scrolls, composed about 2500 years ago with a specific purpose, in a specific region and within a specific culture with a specific cosmology. The planet was only partially known and believed to be flat and the centre of the cosmos, for example.


The "Bad Tree" that Jesus mentioned is not necessarily the "Torah", but the way the texts have been read, used and abused. Jesus is speaking of false prophets in this parable. Those who say they know what the texts mean and what God wants. The false teachings will produce bad fruits, and that´s something anyone can easily see.

All our descriptions, ideas, theories and theologies about God are not facts. Nobody really knows the fullness of this mysterious God, yet we all know some parts, because God reveals Godself to all of us, and all creation. We can all listen to God and I´m 100% sure all of you have heard God sometime. We all have experiences with God, whether we call it God or something else. The great thinkers throughout history have wondered and wrestle with God, or the unknown, and all of them came up with their theory. Yet, we can only have theories and then our own experiences. I´m sure I´m right in some ideas I have as I´m sure there are many things I´m wrong. I´m only 52 years old and I´ve changed my mind so many times already, especially about unknown things as they are only theories to be tested and either accepted or discarded.


These texts, as other texts from other cultures, do tell us about God, but in my opinion they tell us more about how God was perceived back then and not how God is exactly. The texts themselves show an image of God that evolves and changes, but the interpreters of Hebrew Scriptures throughout the ages have been looking and insisting in the idea of an unchangeable God. God´s essence might not change, but God has to be changing as the whole creation keeps changing. And how could God teach us about things of our time and age? What did God ever say in the Hebrew Scriptures about banks or the use of smart phones and social media? God didn't even know that that would one day exist. At least the way I see God as NOT Omniscient .

Right at the start, in the scroll of Genesis, the writers purposefully describe two different creation stories, with two different ways God was perceived. That might not be an editor´s distraction, but a clue on how the texts can be read and how different perspectives are welcome. But still,many may argue and defend something else to fit their stagnant interpretations.


God is love, peace and justice. God is with the oppressed and the persecuted. God is with the ones rejected by society, with those whose rights are not being respected. God is with the oppressors as well for I´m sure they are able to love and do justice, even if it´s just to their own kind, their own group, their own nation, their own race. When the oppressors are making others suffer, the evil in them is hiding God from them and not allowing them to listen to sound judgement. Only when they will allow themselves to listen, they might see and repent. Some might live all their lives hiding from the God within, and that is a shame.

God wants to evolve and end with all wars, all injustices, all violence, all hatred, but God doesn't have a divine body to intervene. God uses humans, those who open themselves to be at service to Love, Justice and Peace, those who dare to be still and listen, those who are willing to be available to be an instrument and to be God´s hands and feet and mouth, because God does not have a physical body. Here we can think of many men and women from all religions who, because of their love for God, devoted themselves to serve others, to care for the poor and needy, to work for peace and justice, to look after their children, their parents or those with special needs.

God wants to evolve with all of us. And it´s up to each one of us to defeat evil in our minds first, and then in our actions.

The war will only end when everyone chooses Peace and Justice, or at least a big majoritty. In the recent ellections in Israel, 53% of voters still support Netanyahu, and therefore all the violence that is perpetrated by him and his commands. Most American Evangelical Christians support Netanyahu and his actions, support the settler and Messianic movement in Palestine, some consciously, some out of ignorance . Basically, many Christians today are supporting genocide, violence, prejudice, hatred and injustice against people God loves.

Slowly all over the world people are standing against fascism and extreme right policies and actions, but it´s still not enough . we are not really free until everyone is free.

I might write another post about the incredible people we met there, doing incredible things for peace , justice and non-violent resistance, but now I think I wanted to address the religious people, in particular those who follow the Abrahamic faiths that are in a way responsible for this conflict and should know better on how to lead their followers.

"Do to others what you would like others to do to you", some say it sums up all of God´s commands. What is so hard about it?

I know this is already long, and thanks for the patience with my ramble if you survived until here, but I just want to share one more thought for our minds. I´m not a roman catholic so I never really noticed before in all the stations of the via dolorosa, which represents the path Jesus did, from his sentence by Pilate until the place he was supposedly crucified, where is now a massive Catholic Church called "The holy Sepulchre" . I actually walked the whole way from the Gethsemane until the sepulchre. 

This image below is the 7th station. I looked intently at each one and this one caught my attention.

 

The guards don't look mean in this image and one of them is even holding the cross for Jesus. "Maybe their hearts were changing", I thought. Maybe the oppressors can change when they are faced with unjustice so close and with such cruelty. Maybe their consciousness can be open and they can hear God shouting ,"it´s enough!".

I prayed and will continue to pray for the IDF soldiers who are obeying orders that will surely contradict their consciousness. I know there is a 20 year old organization called "combatants for peace" who brought Israelis and Palestinians together to co-resist the occupation and help build a better and just future for all. 

The thing is, the love within us eventually shatters all evil.  

That's my hope 

No comments: